I'm no trans expert but.........It could be programming or a shift solenoid hanging. Sometimes disconnecting the battery will fix stuff like this. Allow about 30 minutes then re-connect.
Did the trans ever shift correctly? Take it to the trans shop that rebuilt it for a computer re-flash...at least have it scanned for codes......even if the CEL is off.
Did the trans ever shift correctly? Take it to the trans shop that rebuilt it for a computer re-flash...at least have it scanned for codes......even if the CEL is off.